The guy was a total a$$hole and is solely to blame for everything. Calling her a bitch is way out of line. How would anyone else's demeanor be after dealing with that ******bag? I'm 5' 11" and weigh about 210. Someone reclining in front of me has never affected me in any way. I can understand if someone needs to use a laptop and asking the recliner (who is under no obligation to oblige), but other than that, recline away. The person reclining the seat paid for the space. If you can't deal with that, drive your whiny a$$ there.