I am starting to get January offers from Total Rewards so this may become moot if something better comes along. Last month I got a nice offer for three nights at PH in a Hollywood Hip Room (even though calendar would give me resort) plus $300 in free play. I booked this for a friday through monday along with an executive suite at MGM for monday through thursday (no free play, but the suite upgrade). I am low diamond with just under 20k tier points. Recently I got an offer from Total Rewards for $125 each of free play and resort credit, but with better rooms. (5) nights in any non-suite room at Flamingo, Ballys, and Harrahs (inc. petite suite), 4 nights at Paris (up to Red Room Luxury) and PH (up to Resort room) or Caesars 3 nights up to Octavius Luxury. What would you do? Keep the PH room with $300 free play and hope for an upgrade? Stay at Paris in a Red Room(most likely will get an upgrade to red premier) with Dining/free play? Stay at Caesars with Dining/free play? If I knew I would get the Octavious Room I would stay at Caesars, but I have got burnt and downgraded to Palace before.